Jump to content
<?php echo esc_attr( get_bloginfo( 'name' ) ); ?>
  • 0

He wants to keep it a secret forever! (Also in help/advice section)


Alright, so, this is going to be very long, so if you don't have time on your hands, I suggest you don't get into this. And yes, there is useless and pointless flirting in my description but with good reason. I promise.

I'm very new to this website, I just now made an account so that I can share my experience with all of you. I'm hoping you have some advice to offer. Basically, I have a cousin, and he's my first cousin. He's not removed or anything like that, he's just my first cousin, my mother's brother's son. I've known his sister all my life, and I've been so close with her for so long. She's been my best friend from the very beginning, and she still is to this day. Him, I've only known a few months. He's slightly older than her and was given up for adoption as a baby. It was a closed adoption, so no one in our family even met him or spoke with him until he turned eighteen, which was just a few months ago, in June. I haven't met him in person yet, but I plan to very soon. He lives pretty far away from me, as I am in Florida, and he is in New York.

When we met, it was his sister who initially introduced me to him, and I knew nothing about him. I had no idea what he looked like, sounded like, or even how old he was, but I got to know him very quickly. We are both over eighteen, me being a few months older. The first thing I noticed about him was that he is just the sweetest, he was so happy to be meeting me, and he couldn't stop jumping up and down with excitement and expressing to me how happy the whole thing made him. He had never met any of his biological family before, so his sister and I were the first people he spoke to, and he said, quote, he "felt he was with his people". (I couldn't help but think of Mrs. Puff, lol.)

About a week went by, and we had really bonded a lot, we shared a lot of the same hobbies, especially music. He writes and raps, and I sing, and we both play piano, so we sort of feel we might be able to collaborate. It wasn't long before I started to feel some type of way for him, and I noticed it first when I sent him a picture of me at winter formal with my ex, and I almost wanted him to feel jealous. But that wasn't what made me realize it, what happened was, I confided in him about how cute I felt in the dress, and he said, "You're always adorable." My heart fluttered, and I couldn't help but hope that maybe he was flirting with me. But he was my cousin, so I tried to brush it off, and just said "Nah". However, he kept going and continued to flirt, saying things like "What? It's true!" and "YA FACE. IS CUTE." I tried to deny my feelings for him, telling myself it was just because I had just met him, but after a few days, I still felt this way. And the crazy thing was, he brought it up to me a few days later, saying that he had been talking to his biological mother about how apparently cousin marriages are legal in around half the states, and she said, "You can't date your cousin. You know that right?" and he played it off like he thought it was funny for her to suggest such a thing, but then he slowly eased his way into it. First, it was "If we weren't cousins", and when I admitted feeling the same way, he admitted that he was starting to like me. And from there, we decided that we would try to be in a long distance relationship, and for two weeks, it worked perfectly. We were very happy together, and we fell in love so quickly. I cannot express how deeply in love I am with him, I really can't imagine myself with anyone else. He talks about building a future with me, getting married, having kids, living together in a beach house, making music together. It all seems so perfect.

We have broken up twice... Both times, he ended it. He says he was afraid, and he felt like it can't work, because our family will feel some type of way about it, and he isn't sure what type of way that is, exactly. He also said he doesn't want to risk losing the family he just got back, and I completely understand this. However, we both found that at this point, neither of us can go even a few days without each other. He even tried being with someone else immediately after a breakup, which didn't work at all. He ended up breaking up with her almost immediately and getting back with me. We haven't broken up since then, and he's promised to stay with me from now on because he's had enough of that bull.

But... This is where the problem comes in. He wants to keep it a secret from our family... Forever. Yes, forever. Not just hide it until we feel comfortable enough, he wants to just hide it from everyone for the rest of our lives, and I don't think that's going to work. I, myself, am eager for my family to know. If it were up to me, I would tell everyone right now, because I wanna show the world, this is my boyfriend, and I love him more than anything else in the entire world. But, at the same time, I understand that he just got this family back. His sister is aware of our feelings for each other, as well as the past two times we were together, (she's not judging, but she feels like I sort of made her the third wheel) but he wants to keep it a secret from her this time. He says no one we told before ever truly approved, and he feels like it got in the way of our relationship, and that's where it went wrong. He says he really, really wants it to work this time, and that's why he wants to keep it from everyone and tell absolutely no one.

What is your take on all this? And I apologize for the story being so very long, lol.

P.S. Other people who know include my mother, my father, my aunt (my mother's sister), his best friend (who is also my friend now), his ex-girlfriend/best girl friend, his friend, his cousin, and a few of my own friends. Our friends seem to be okay with it, for the most part, not judging at all. My mother and father don't particularly like it, but they aren't disowning me, they aren't seeing or treating me differently, and they aren't trying to interfere or cause problems. They just don't agree with it. However, my father has admitted he will not feel comfortable walking me down the aisle... :(

Link to post
Share on other sites

6 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
  • Old Timer

I'm a little confused by your story 1) you two are dating, but you've never actually met? ("I haven't met him in person yet, but I plan to very soon.") 2) He's already broken up with you twice, once getting together with someone else immediately afterwards?, and 3) You are both 18, correct?

Assuming I got all three of those things right, this doesn't sound like a serious thing. Maybe meet him before you start talking about forever, in any context.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
  • Administrator

i'm with miss price on this one. you can never really KNOW a person (much less truly love them) until you've been around them in real life. it sucks, i know, but the intensity of your feelings is built on a cloud... a cyber-cloud. one that can disappear at any moment. try not to get caught up in the fantasy of marrying him right now. marriage is one of those phenomenons that require sharing a home day-in and day-out. it requires being able to carry on a conversation without a cell phone in your hand. it requires putting down your cell phone to help wash dishes and cook dinners. it requires a LIFETIME of having to spend time in each other's physical presence putting their needs ahead of your own. 

and at this point in time, you've never even been in the same room with each other.

don't get ahead of yourselves.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I've been in long distance relationships before, and I completely agree with you guys. Marriage isn't something we need to discuss right now, I do agree with that. However, this is different somehow, completely different. It feels different, like I've been in long distance relationships, and I've been in "in-person" relationships, so to speak. And I've been in love with people I knew in person and none of that has ever even gotten close to how I feel now, and I don't understand it either. It's quite confusing for both of us. I mean, my grandparents met online and they've been together at least twenty years. I have hope. I love him a lot. And everyone keeps saying you can't love someone you've never met, but I do. I'm sad to say my parents have both said this exact same thing, along with "It will never work, there is no hope." I just disagree in this particular situation. If it were anyone else I might look into it long and hard and say "Maybe they're right" but this is different, so I usually tell them to shove it lol.

And like I said, I do agree with you on the whole marriage thing, but that was all him. He brought it up, and I didn't really get excited or anything about it, it's not exactly something I look forward to yet, it's just something that makes me feel like he really loves me. If he wants to spend the rest of his life with me, I'm all for it, but we do have to meet first.

Which is coming soon. I think, like, maybe 3 weeks from now. He's buying a plane ticket for me so I can go see him. I'm so freaking excited ohmygosh. I feel like I'm about to go to some Walker Stalker event to meet Chandler Riggs, I'm soooooo excited, I can't even contain it.

Edited by mayaangellou
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Hello Maya,

i pressume from your (nick)name that your origin is hellenic (greek), as mine. As far as i can see, things are not that bad in your story. They could be far worse, believe me. It is a huge open window of hope the fact that your own family isn't very hostile with the idea itself of you dating your cousin. Thinking of marriage this now is too early, you have a whole life ahead of you two to make plans for it. Concerning love stories between first or second cousins within the so called western societies (North America and Europe) i came to the following conclusion after having read too much in the internet and contacted people that have a love connection with a relative of 4th degree and forth... :

  • one of the two sees the whole situation either in panic/guilty/strange state . This seems to be by far the most common situation for this kind of couple in love. They usually keep it secret from family.
  • both sides see their situation negatively, described as above. Again, they usually keep it secret.
  • both sides neglect any pressure, or they feel ok with what they have and life goes on normally for them.

It seems you belong to the first group. I wish you all the best with your boyfriend (i emphasize the man aspect of him, not the relational deliberately) because such stories demand durability, strength and of course good luck, especially when they involve distance. All the best Maya.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
  • Administrator
22 hours ago, Santoro said:

i pressume from your (nick)name that your origin is hellenic (greek), as mine.

fyi, she's probably not. the real maya angelou was an american, best known for her poetry and civil rights activism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_Angelou

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Similar Content

    • By The Riddler
      Hey guys,
      Apologies if I make mistakes, very new here. I’m extremely happy that there is a community like this, in the world we live in.
      I need your opinion on my situation. 
      Off the bat, I’m in love with my first cousin and I’m sure she feels like same but I need to be 100% sure so that I can make a move becoz I intend to. 
      We are an affectionate family, we all hug and kiss.
      I’m 24 (m) and she’s 32(f) married with 2 children who I get along with well. She’s in a toxic marriage that won’t last much longer. 
      This sexual tension between us has been building over the last 2 years. 
      Whenever we see each other, we always sit next to each other and our legs touch etc for example she’ll always use my knee as support when she gets up IMO just to touch my leg. 
      We were recently under a blanket and I made a move to hold her hand but interlocked hand holding which she was okay with. I have hugged her from behind and she likes it. 
      When I hug her it’s always a bit longer plus my hands are around her waist and our legs always touch, we always give a bit more of a kiss than a usual peck. Not sure if I’m reading too much into it. 
      When she fixes my pants becoz they falling down she will let her hand run across my bum. 
      I often pass each other by and give a little shoulder rub or a hand glide on the back. 
      Im definitely more forward than she is but she has never seemed uncomfortable with the interactions and has initiated some herself. She regularly puts her feet under my legs.
      I think she might be holding back for the same reason i am. 
      What do you guys think and how should I make a move? I’ve already held her hand and now I’d like to French kiss her and cuddling. 
      Possibly make love if it can get to that. I love her a lot. 
      Kind regards, 
      The riddler 
  • Create New...